SAY IT ONCE

Dog Blog. Thoughts. TIps.

  • Home
  • OUR TRAINING
  • Sign Up!
  • Select an Appointment
  • Group Class Sign Ups
    • Pittsburgh PA
    • Nashville TN
    • Cincinnati OH
  • Seminar Series
    • Tampa
    • Boston
    • Washington DC
  • MERCH
  • Virtual Training
  • Say It Once Rescue League
  • Dog Derby
  • Farm Training
  • Drop-Off Day Training
    • @ The Dog House
    • South Hills w/ Erin
  • THE DOG HOUSE
  • Blog
  • Videos
  • Testimonials
  • Gift Card

9/19/2022

Why I Hate Hand Signals

3 Comments

Read Now
 
Do you want to know why I hate hand signals? 


There is a few reasons why I hate using hand signals in dog training, and I’m going to go over the biggest two. I always get push back from owners on, but my dog listens really well to the hand signal. I know they do! I know they learn faster through using hand signals (also understand them when teaching all behaviors we lure with our hand, and develop a hand signal with every command. However, I do immediately get away from using the hand signal when I feel like the dog has an understanding of the word. Let’s go over why.


  1. Hand signals are only reliable when your dog is looking at you. Do you I think I’m going to have a hard time getting my dog to listen if I have their 100 percent attention? No. Your verbal cue needs to be strong because you are going to rely on this in almost all scenarios, whether your dog is looking at you or not, whether your hands are full or not, or whether you are looking at your dog or not. Hand signals can only be done in one of those scenarios. That’s not good enough.
  2. Humans lack the ability to separate word from hand sign. Your word should always come first. Always. When teaching your dog sit, down anything, before you offer a hand signal, you must say the word for your dog to understand. Think of this. If I where to punch you in the face and say purple at the same time, and repeat this process three times, the fourth time that I say purple without punching you in the face you're gonna have no idea what's going to happen next because you never had time to process the purple man punch in the face. You were too worried about the physical feeling of punch in the face instead of listening to the word purple. However if I said purple, delayed a half a second and punched you, repeated a second time, on the third attempt that I say purple you would be ducking out of the way like you're in the movie the matrix. This is also how do you have to train your dog. You need to incorporate the verbal cue before there is any movement from your body.




If you don't believe me, I want you to try training your dog on all of their commands this week without moving your body at all. Film yourself, and watch. See if your dog can listen to only with your verbal cue, and see if they listen quickly. If they're not, we need to go back to the basics. I want you to tag yourself while training your dog with the #Sayitoncehandsfree Tag me in it, and let’s see how you train without your hand signals!






P.S. I teach all of my dogs and my clients dogs on hand signals, the dog understands and very quickly, but I get away from them immediately because I want to focus more on my verbal cue. That doesn't mean I will never use a hand signal, it just means that I need to put more emphasis type my words need power.

Share

3 Comments
Diane Warstler
10/7/2022 10:36:22 pm

Hey Vinnie, I found this to be very interesting. I have always found I was very pleased when my dogs would do everything by just hand signals and no verbal. I It seemed much easier for the verbal commands to stick. Interesting tho!! I like your videos. Congrats on your successful business!!!!
Regard, Diane

Reply
Susan
11/29/2022 06:55:35 am

I like to retain hand signals for some basic commands, but you do have to continue to use them through the years. That’s work for the lazy human.When the dog gets older and hearing deteriorates a bit, those basic directions can be communicated when needed; like traveling or vet care when they are unsure of the setting or physically having issues with body strength (like hips and legs). Their needs change and we adapt to what works for them best as they age into seniors or have more medical issues. Currently exploring the idea of the audio/vibration collars compared to stem collars as some senior dogs hear a particular range of tones, but not others. Seems like a possible alternative when using long lines for hiking.

Reply
Dog training Austin TX link
1/26/2023 08:17:55 am

This is a good point! I think too often people rely on hand signals and forget about the power of their voice. Dogs are incredibly attuned to our vocal cues and can pick up on a lot of meaning that we might not even be aware of. So, while hand signals can be helpful, they should always take a backseat to our verbal commands.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

Details

    Vinnie Somma

    I Train dogs well. Spelling is questionable

    Archives

    October 2022
    September 2022
    July 2022
    April 2022
    February 2022
    November 2021
    September 2021
    June 2021
    September 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    December 2018
    February 2017

    Categories

    All
    Playtime

    RSS Feed

Say It Once Dog Training

Dogs meet our needs with their unconditional love everyday.  Return the favor, call today to learn how to become not just a dog lover, but a knowledgeable dog owner! Your dog will thank you for it.


Hours

Monday-Sunday: 9am - 9pm

Telephone

412-427-7507

Email

sayitoncedt@gmail.com
  • Home
  • OUR TRAINING
  • Sign Up!
  • Select an Appointment
  • Group Class Sign Ups
    • Pittsburgh PA
    • Nashville TN
    • Cincinnati OH
  • Seminar Series
    • Tampa
    • Boston
    • Washington DC
  • MERCH
  • Virtual Training
  • Say It Once Rescue League
  • Dog Derby
  • Farm Training
  • Drop-Off Day Training
    • @ The Dog House
    • South Hills w/ Erin
  • THE DOG HOUSE
  • Blog
  • Videos
  • Testimonials
  • Gift Card